I can already imagine the arguments on this column's online comment thread,
so I'll respond to some of them in advance:
It's just a word.
Language has power; it affects us consciously and subconsciously. The word
bitch isn't a problem because it's offensive or because it may make some women
feel bad when they hear it. It's a problem because it perpetuates dangerous
gender stereotypes, the same notions that result in tangible discrimination like
male-female wage disparity. Its common usage makes it seem like it's a bad thing
for a woman to be assertive or strong. For instance, it makes it seem like it's
OK not to vote for Hillary Clinton because she doesn't fit old-fashioned views
of a woman's role in society.
Isn't this just overzealous political correctness?
No. I'm not proposing that we pretend the word doesn't exist. As you may have
noticed, it appears often throughout this column. It's just not OK to refer to
anyone derogatorily as a bitch.
Even if the person you're referring to is a guy?
Even then, because the word is still rooted in prejudice and misogyny. When
you're calling a guy a bitch, you're basically calling him a woman. That
shouldn't be an insult - just like calling someone gay or black or Jewish
shouldn't be an insult.
Haven't you used it regularly in private conversation just like everyone
else, you hypocrite?
Yes, but I stopped when I realized how unacceptable it is. I'm no different
from you, and your life will be no worse when you stop using it.
Shouldn't women try to reclaim ownership of the word and change its
meaning?
Maybe, but I doubt it will work. A better strategy is to trumpet how
unacceptable it is, noting its obvious ties to misogyny. No matter what
feminists decide it should mean, it will still connote ill-tempered women,
portraying their lack of submissiveness as a negative.
Why go after "bitch"? Aren't "cunt," "whore" and a few other words just as
bad?
Yes, but "bitch" is more ubiquitous. It's also seen as more acceptable. Watch
network television for an hour and count the number of times it's used. I don't
think any words should be prohibited from network TV, but I do think a healthy
society should balk at the usage of "bitch" if it also protests the usage of
racist words.
You're a prude.
Fine, but in this case a little prudence is necessary.
Karl Stampfl was the Daily's fall/winter editor in chief in 2007. He can
be reached at kstampfl@umich.edu.